Choosing The Right Knife

choosing the right knife

We’ve avoided it long enough, the pure gear discussion. And make no mistake, we’ll avoid it more in the future, because that’s a rabbit hole more than half the industry is stuck in, and all of its marketers, because that’s their job. We respect it, but our mission is to provide you with information you can’t get anywhere else. It may mean we move a little less merchandise over the short run. Because we don’t operate in those fits and starts that come with practically every gear maker out there dancing their way between discounts and specials, because in the long run it means we get to talk about things that operate on more levels, like the philosophy behind the List of All Things that really isn’t a list of anything, and maybe we get to build some trust along the way.

But there’s a few things we just have to get down to, so you know we know what we’re talking about, from experience, from research, and just from the love of all things, yes, including gear. For example, we put up a knife discussion a while back and got a whole lot of feedback, asking why we didn’t get into bushcraft knives, and only mentioned KA-BAR. That was an example, admittedly an old one, but if you dip a little toe into the world of knives, well get ready, because they’re everywhere, everyone’s got an opinion, there’s a ton of great information already out there from people who specialize solely in knives, and the prices are often changing. What was an incredible bargain less than two years ago is now selling for upwards of $200, and has every right to. Yet there are still old school brands available that will sell you what you need for under $20. So we decided just to speak generally about why the knife is the one tool that tops the List, and we predicted we’d get a whole lot of--let’s call it feedback--so we weren’t disappointed.

Knives For The Family

But we’re on the subject of go bags, particularly that conundrum between packing one for yourself, versus making sure you’ve divvied up the load appropriately in case you’ve got a group. Does every single pack need its own knife? Short answer? Yes, and all razor sharp. We’ll leave it up to you parents to disagree, based on your children’s age, but some of us had knives when we were seven, and our older brothers showed us how to use theirs when we were five. Kids respect them if you impress upon them how to handle them right, just like school teachers do with their students the first time they let them use scissors.

So, let’s use a family of four with two kids around 7 and 10 as our base example. You can extrapolate from there for all ages and numbers. This means we’re recommending buying four knives right out of the chute, not to mention sturdy backpacks of varying sizes, a collection of appropriate clothing, and sleeping bags. Not to mention pads, tents, shoes, first aid kits, cups, bowls, spoons, and a few other items that begin to tail off on the priority list.

Even if you’re not on a budget, the idea of buying a bunch of stuff you hope you’ll never use and hardly ever see again...? Because keep in mind, we’re envisioning a true bug out situation as something like a fire in your home during the kind of pandemic we’re in. This means if you’re frequently switching items between your bug out bags and camping gear, you risk not having your bug out bags absolutely ready at all times, which defeats the purpose.

Price Points

Also, the truth is, when we experience emergencies other people are likely out to lend a helping hand and nobody cares what you’re carrying, whether it’s cheap emergency stuff or worth a used car.

But tweak a few variables, and you could easily imagine a circumstance where you don’t necessarily want to be walking down the street with thousands of dollars of gear shining in any stranger’s eyes, and on the other hand you don’t want it splitting at the seams or breaking after ten minutes of use.

Using knives as just one example, ask practically any survivalist or outdoor aficionado what the best quality, cheapest option is out there for a knife and most will admit that the Swedish company, Mora, has set the standard for a long time. The Morakniv Companion sells for around $18, including tough plastic sheath designed just for it, and comes with absolutely excellent steel. Their “Basic” model is sometimes available for as low as $10, and while a short blade, is also excellent steel and comes with a sheath. Frankly, we don’t know how they do it, but we’re glad they do.

Full Tang

The first thing anyone will mention is these aren’t “full tang” knives, meaning the blade extends into the handle, but is not full and fat steel all the way to the back. What do you want for around fifteen dollars? The only reason survivalists even lean toward “full tang” is in case you really need to abuse your knife to the point you wish you had a hatchet. The standard for this kind of abuse is “batoning”, and now we are really getting into the kind of detail that you can find explained, filmed, youtubed, and hashed over by knife aficionados a thousand times over. And just about every single one of them will admit, the Mora Companion in a bugout bag is absolutely smart, economical, and will not let you down. If you want to spend $200 on a great hand-crafted knife, we are all for it, but we generally can’t stand not taking ours out for a spin every once in a while as opposed to staying tucked permanently in their emergencies-only place.

If you really need “full tang” you can still get a sub $15 knife: Old Hickory. You go check your grandmother’s or great grandmother’s cutlery drawer right now, and odds are she’s got her favorite chef’s knife that may be a pretty well known brand, and right next to it a wooden handled Old Hickory that’ll bring back memories a whole lot of people didn’t know they had. She’ll use the chef’s knife for every vegetable in sight and all the fillets, but if there’s something that might have a bone, or otherwise presents knick potential...yep, Old Hickory to the rescue. But you get what you pay for. The steel in the handle is thin, and while we’ve tested Old Hickory’s and the best we can say is they do the job of a knife, we would would prefer trusting something a little higher up on the scale in any true survival situation.

That said, KA-BAR makes sub $15 sheaths that they sell separately, that fit Old Hickory knives just fine. Whether you get a sheath you can use on a hip belt or shoulder strap on your pack, or just a safe case so you can tuck the knife in a ready-access pocket of your go bag, either way you’ll need something to keep that blade covered.

Not Fixated On Fixed Blades

On that note, a lot of people may say, if you recommend Mora, which is not full tang, are you stuck on “fixed blade” at all? What about a pocket knife that folds up, or a multi tool? Yep, their fine too. While all of us here prefer fixed blade for true survival, truth is we all have a multi tool and a pocket knife or two. Maybe that seven year old of yours just loves the mechanism of a folding, locking blade. We say go for it. Odds are a nice quality pocket knife will handle its own fair share of abuse, as long as you remember, when in doubt, go with fewer moving parts. Those Mora knives offer several different colors in the handle, and some of us who’ve packed a family set of go bags went ahead and got two Mora Companions of different colors for the kids, and two Mora Garberg full tang versions that are upwards of $80 each.

Again, our regular blades for camping are not the ones we keep in our go bags for the most part. Each of us browsed all the knives out there, including those brilliant handmade ones by a whole lot of hobbyist artisans, and pros out there, and while we think $200 for a knife that’s meant to be used is on the high side, at the same time we know what goes into making them by hand, and we like to support these people for keeping alive one of the most essential skills that separate mankind from the beasts. And you know what? The good ones are so well respected and popular, they can’t make them fast enough. They’re always out of stock, and many of them could be selling for $400 or more just because of demand. We would love to list them for you, but there are so many it’s amazing. Several companies started out in a workshed, and some still operate out of one. Some have grown up, charge double what they used to because their name has earned the recognition, and we feel if we list a few, we’d be excluding twenty others who deserve to be named just as much. If you go on Instagram and search “knives”, well, we’ll talk to you next month, because it’ll take that long to find you in the rabbit hole, but it’s a fun one. Filled with artisans, craftsmen, their tools, their opinions not only on knives but wilderness survival, workshop machines, materials, and best practices on all sorts of things. And don’t even let them get started on sharpening!

Just Scratching The Surface

Now you see? We just barely scratched the surface and haven’t gone into any of the other gear specifics we’ve been planning on getting to for your bug out bags. So we’ll cut this off here for now and trust that if you need to learn more, there’s plenty out there on knives alone for you to wade into.

Free Karambit Raptor Knife

This FREE Spring-Loaded Karambit Knife Shreds Flesh & Tough Material Like A Razor-Steel Raptor Claw

Click Here For Free Karambit Knife
Click Here to Leave a Comment Below
Dave - May 11, 2020 Reply

Thank you for the great tips and help in understanding what’s needed in different events.

Garry Bryant - May 11, 2020 Reply

Just do research; check out youtube videos, reviews. As said this subject is endless. Basically subscribe to multi knife use: pocket knife for EDC, 2-4 inch blade for bushcraft & food prep, 5-6 inch for survival and very small batoning, 7-9 inch for batoning & chopping. The later I’m still trying to decide. I’m blown away with a knife costing over $150 bucks! Trying to justify right now the cost of $250 for a 7.” Also learn which steel is best for the job you expect to do. 1095 seems the most mention due to it being high carbon, maintains an edge, and easy to sharpen, but will rust easily. But there are other steels as good if not better. I stay away from stainless steel due to poor performance in striking a ferro rod for sparks. Fixed knife get one that has 90 degree spine for striking ferro rod. Good luck trying to decide. LOL

Ralph - May 17, 2020 Reply

Good article I am a knife collector,having 300 knives and love them all, carry one for a month then clean it up and pick another.

billy bishop - May 22, 2020 Reply

I ordered this tac watch you had and you added 47.00 dollars for something else and canceled it , but it is still on my credit card. Please removed it please.

    Black Ops Tac - June 11, 2020 Reply

    I’m sorry you are having issues. Here is the email address to reach customer service to get this sorted out:

Anthony Dell - July 19, 2020 Reply

I ordered 2 of the raptur knifes over 4 weeks ago, and I haven’t received them, and I need the postal # too.

    Black Ops Tac - July 23, 2020 Reply

    I’m sorry you are having issues. Here is the email address to reach customer service to get this sorted out:

Johnny Crumpton - July 28, 2020 Reply

Just one knife for everything… my choice is the Marine K-bar, very versatile and if it is good enough for the Marines it is good enough for me.

Charles Ford - August 14, 2020 Reply

I bought the gold president coins and yet to get an emailed receipt or any information when I would receive them and placed the order a week ago

    Black Ops Tac - August 14, 2020 Reply

    I’m sorry you are having issues. Here is the email address to reach customer service to get this sorted out:

Ryan Leishman - August 17, 2020 Reply

I have to have a full tang of course, handle that holds back. For the blade a 10″ to 12″ Kukri bladed knife is the end All, do all, be all!!!

    Ron Driver - February 11, 2021 Reply

    there are several knife styles around the world that can replace the Bowie.
    a Kukri is 1 such with certainty. full tang blades beat a half blades and at tails. factory knives are mostly 440 stainless steel no matter fixed or folding. the great majority will come in 3mm thick blades. if your one of the total morons who use your knives as pry bars or screwdrivers etc you will damage a factory knife quickly. if you have some semblance of a brain and knife use savvy you can get a lot out of a factory knife. use different knives
    for defense, hunting, skinning, cooking, camping type chores, clearing brush, shaving and so on…and this means you will need to carry some place between 3 to 7 knives right out of the chute.

Cass - September 14, 2020 Reply

It’s a full tang life for a full tang girl.

Monte Montierth - September 17, 2020 Reply

Looking for the catch.

Donna - October 20, 2020 Reply

A lot of info but I think I will pass up this one.Thank you.

    Ronnie D - February 11, 2021 Reply

    hello Donna. i want you to reconsider. there are pocket knives, fixed blade knives, and kitchen knives you WILL want and NEED. guaranteed.
    a knife has been a proven pal of ours for thousands of years. as i see it they are often your best tool if not your life saver.
    defense. cooking. camping chores or around the house chores. shaving. hunting. skinning. fishing. making tools or weapons. etc
    YOU NEED at bare bone minimum a 12 to 15 inch bowie.
    an 8 to 12 inch gut knife/skinner.
    an folding knife with a 4 inch blade/5 inch handle.
    a kitchen chef knife 8 to 12 inch.
    a camping axe 22 inches overall/multi use
    a meat cleaver 12 to 14 inches overall with a thick blade.
    you will take these knives to a pro and have them sharpened even if you
    think they are already sharp … unless the pro decides 1 or 2 need no work

Leave a Comment: